Repost: Etheldred Benett – “Lady Geologist”

This is from 2014, slightly revised.

In the late 18th and early 19th century, men like James Hutton and Sir William Hamilton were widely respected earth scientists.

At the same time women were also helping to found the science of geology, but their contributions were often overlooked by the day’s scientific establishment.

For instance, meet T. Etheldred Benett, 1776-1845 – fossil collector, stratigrapher, and scientific correspondent. The image above, thanks to The Geological Society, is one of only a few clues we have today of what she looked like.

However, her work has left a lasting impression.

This “lady of great talent and indefatigable research,” as Gideon Mantell described her:

  • Left behind a huge collection of Cretaceous and Jurassic fossils from south Wiltshire in England, including the first mollusc fossils ever found that contained preserved bits of the original soft anatomy
  • Corresponded with some of the foremost naturalists of the day
  • Wrote a publication, A catalogue of the organic remains of the county of Wiltshire (1831), that remains a classic work today

In a time when women weren’t admitted to centers of higher learning, Tsar Nicholas I gave her an honorary doctorate from the University of St. Petersburg — but only because he thought her first name was that of a man.

Library of Congress
In the late 19th century, Walter Shirlaw painted the spirit of geology as a woman for the Library of Congress.

Ever the sharp commentator, Miss Benett (she never married) said of the incident (link added):

They have made me a member of the Imperial Natural History Society of Moscow and have sent me a Diploma of the appointment, but it is provoking that no one will believe that a Lady could write such a trifling thing – in this Diploma I am called Dominum Etheldredum Benett and Mr Lyell told me that he had been written to by foreigners to know if Miss Benett was not a Gentleman … So you see that scientific people in general have a very low opinion of the abilities of my sex.

In such an environment, how did women like Etheldred Benett and her younger contemporary Mary Anning get started?

Dr. Martina Koelbl-Ebert, director of the Jura-Museum Eichstatt in Bavaria, says that it had to do with the lack of competition for jobs.

In the late 18th century, geology was already professionalized in Germany. Alexander von Humboldt,for example, began his career as an employee of the Prussian mines department. Women couldn’t get a foot in the door.

Things were more informal in Great Britain, where proto-geologists were more likely to be individual enthusiasts with the means to indulge their interests in the field. These men welcomed the participation of women who shared their interests and could assist them.

Etheldred Benett was an independently wealthy enthusiast whose connection into the world of British science was through her sister-in-law’s brother Aylmer Bourke Lambert, a botanist. She went on to correspond with everyone from the lowly-born and little known (at the time) William Smith to William Buckland, Dean of Westminster and fellow of the Royal Society.

Meteorite, by Etheldred Benett.  Source
Meteorite, by Etheldred Benett. Source

By 1809, geologists were visiting her fossil collection.

In 1815, she presented to the Royal Society a cross-section of the Upper Chicksgrove quarry at Tisbury, in Wiltshire, that she had commissioned and produced.

In 1825 she also gave the Society a painting she had done of a meteorite that had landed in Ireland in 1813.

Her 1831 Catalogue was dedicated to George Bellas Greenough, first president of the Geological Society. In 1832, the current president, Sir Roderick Murchison, referred to her book in his 1832 address to the Geological Society.

During her last twenty years or so, Benett’s health failed. She had to pay collectors to go out into the field. When she died in 1845, most of her collection was bought by a Delaware physician and taken to America, where it has ended up in the Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia. A smaller collection is also stored in Britain.

Mary Anning is more generally remembered by the general public, perhaps because of “she sells seashells by the sea shore.” But Etheldred Benett helped open the way for Mary and other women to participate in and help build the new scientific discipline of geology.

Thanks, Etheldred!  Source
Thanks, Etheldred! Source



More information:

One comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.